Comparison of Radiofrequency Microtenotomy vs. Heavy-Slow Resistance for Refractory Plantar Fasciopathy: A Randomised Controlled Trial
Sports medicine - open · 2026
In refractory plantar fasciopathy, radiofrequency microtenotomy showed no advantage over heavy-slow resistance training at 6 months, so try loading first.
Part of: Tendinopathy: what actually helps and what to avoid · Foot and ankle injuries in sport · Surgery versus conservative care: when does the operation earn its place?
The paper
RCT, n=82 randomised / 72 analysed (74% female), patients with refractory plantar fasciopathy.
What they found
No significant between-group difference in the primary outcome, change in FHSQ-DK pain from baseline to 6 months (mean difference -4.9, 95% CI -13.8 to 4.0). Secondary outcomes were similar between groups at essentially every comparison, with one exception: Global Perceived Effect for ability to perform sport differed between groups at 1 month only (P<0.05), a finding that didn't persist at later time points and is most plausibly a chance result given the number of comparisons tested. No serious adverse events occurred in either arm (4 vs 5 patients with minor adverse events).
Study design
Randomised controlled superiority trial comparing radiofrequency microtenotomy against a self-dosed heavy-slow resistance programme, 82 randomised and 72 analysed, in adults with refractory plantar fasciopathy, registered on clinicaltrials.gov (NCT03854682).
Methodology
Randomisation was used but the abstract gives no detail on allocation concealment, and blinding is effectively impossible here, patients know whether they had a procedure or are doing a home exercise programme, so performance and detection bias on a self-reported outcome (FHSQ-DK) are real risks. About 12% of randomised patients were excluded from the final analysis and it's unclear whether this was intention-to-treat or per-protocol. The confidence interval on the primary outcome is wide (-13.8 to 4.0), which a clinician should read as a signal of limited power rather than a precise null, meaning the trial can rule out neither a moderate advantage for microtenotomy nor one for resistance training.
The appraisal
This is a statistically null result in a trial that was powered to detect superiority, not designed or powered to prove equivalence, so 'no difference' should not be read as 'equally effective' with confidence. The wide CI straddles values that could still be clinically meaningful in either direction, so the headline conclusion (don't prefer microtenotomy) is reasonable on pragmatic grounds, cost, invasiveness, risk, but is not a tight statistical finding. Neither patients nor assessors could be blinded, and there was no sham procedure; in surgery-versus-exercise trials that usually biases results toward the invasive arm through expectation effects, so the fact that RF still showed no measurable edge makes the null result more credible, not less. The heavy-slow resistance programme was also self-dosed rather than closely supervised, so this trial likely represents a conservative test of what structured loading can achieve.
The gap
The trial cannot distinguish a true null effect from an underpowered comparison; a formally powered non-inferiority design, or a larger sample, would be needed before stating with confidence that the two treatments are clinically equivalent. It also can't fully separate 'exercise doesn't add value over microtenotomy' from 'this particular self-dosed exercise protocol wasn't delivered at full fidelity', since loading progression and adherence weren't externally supervised or reported in detail.
Landmark context
Heavy-slow resistance protocols build on the tendon-loading literature popularised by Kongsgaard's work in patellar tendinopathy and Alfredson-style eccentric loading for Achilles tendinopathy, extended here to plantar fasciopathy. Radiofrequency microtenotomy has a much thinner evidence base in plantar fasciopathy, mostly case series, so this trial is one of relatively few head-to-head comparisons against an active exercise comparator rather than sham or usual care.
What to do Monday
For refractory plantar fasciopathy, this supports trying a structured heavy-slow resistance programme before referring for radiofrequency microtenotomy, since the invasive option showed no added benefit over exercise and carries procedural risk and cost; it does not establish that either treatment is strongly effective on its own.
In practice
This applies to patients with genuinely refractory plantar fasciopathy, ie those who have already failed a reasonable course of first-line conservative care, not to new-onset heel pain. In the clinic, use this to justify committing to a properly supervised, progressive heavy-slow resistance block (loaded, slow-tempo calf raise progressions) for at least 12 weeks before referring on for radiofrequency microtenotomy, since the invasive option added no measurable benefit over exercise despite trial conditions that, if anything, would favour it through expectation effects. Baseline and re-test load tolerance with the Single Leg Calf Raise (or Single Leg Barbell Calf Raise where load needs to be quantified) to dose the HSR programme objectively and to have an evidence-based trigger for escalating care if capacity plateaus despite adequate dosage, rather than referring on time elapsed alone. On the performance floor, the same logic holds for athletes with stubborn plantar heel pain: keep heavy, slow resisted loading as the default pathway alongside modified training, and treat a self-reported, poorly supervised home exercise programme as an inadequate trial of loading, not evidence that exercise has failed.
The five papers that matter — every week, free.
We read the whole sports-medicine, rehab & performance literature and appraise the papers worth your time.
Get the free weekly issueRelated appraisals
Read in your language: English · Français · Deutsch · Español · Italiano · Nederlands · Dansk · Svenska