Watch this space Quality score: 48/100

Playing Surface Characteristics and Their Effects on Football Performance Across Multiple Surface Types: A Systematic Review

Sports medicine - open · 2026

KeyGPS GPSRCT Randomised Controlled TrialS&C Strength and Conditioning

A well-registered review confirms playing surface affects load and fatigue, but heterogeneity means no usable numbers for clinical decisions yet.

sports-medicinestrength-conditioningathletic-trainingload-managementinjury-preventionendurance-physiology

Part of: Hamstring and muscle injury: rehabilitation and return to play · Training load and injury risk: what the evidence says · Injury prevention and screening in sport · Endurance performance and physiology: training the aerobic engine

The paper

Systematic review (PRISMA, PROSPERO-registered), 16 studies pooled narratively, football players tested on natural grass, artificial turf, and/or sand.

What they found

No pooled effect sizes are reported, the review is a narrative synthesis: several studies found higher sprint frequency, acceleration demands and total running distance on artificial turf versus grass, but results were inconsistent across studies; sand consistently increased metabolic cost and reduced running efficiency; heart rate, lactate, neuromuscular and perceptual outcomes were all described as variable or inconsistent, with only isolated evidence of greater residual hamstring fatigue after artificial turf exposure.

Study design

Systematic review of 16 original studies (screened from 814 records) comparing natural grass, artificial turf and sand during football-specific activity; mixed primary designs (non-randomized interventions and cross-sectional studies), so this sits well below a meta-analysis on the evidence hierarchy despite the PRISMA/PROSPERO framework.

Methodology

Risk of bias was assessed with ROBINS-I (non-randomized studies) and an adapted Newcastle-Ottawa Scale for cross-sectional studies, which is appropriate given no RCTs exist in this space, but the authors chose narrative synthesis rather than meta-analysis because of 'substantial methodological heterogeneity' in designs, surface comparisons and outcome measures, meaning there is no pooled effect size, confidence interval or dose-response estimate a clinician could lean on. The abstract itself flags that most included studies did not objectively measure mechanical surface properties (shock absorption, deformation, rotational traction), so a clinician has no way to verify which specific surface attribute drove any reported difference, and surface familiarity (a plausible confounder) was not controlled for across the pooled studies.

The appraisal

This is hypothesis-generating, not practice-defining: the lack of a quantitative pooled estimate and the explicit heterogeneity mean you cannot say artificial turf 'causes' X% more load or Y% more fatigue, only that some studies observed a direction of difference and others did not. Even the most consistent finding, sand's higher metabolic cost, is physiologically unsurprising and doesn't tell you how large the training/injury-risk effect is in absolute terms. The underlying designs (cross-sectional, non-randomized) and the narrative method mean this supports association only, not causal claims about surface and performance or injury.

The gap

Standardized, directly comparable mechanical surface measurements (shock absorption, traction, deformation) paired with controlled, repeated-measures designs within the same players and controlling for surface familiarity, which the review itself identifies as missing across the literature.

Landmark context

This builds on a long-running applied sports science literature comparing third-generation artificial turf to natural grass (much of it tied to FIFA/UEFA surface certification and injury surveillance work), but it does not point to a single foundational RCT or landmark trial; the field has historically relied on injury surveillance cohorts and biomechanics lab comparisons rather than a definitive index study, and this review mainly confirms that inconsistency persists rather than resolving it.

What to do Monday

No, this should not change Monday's training or pitch-selection decisions on its own. It supports being mindful that sand sessions raise metabolic cost (useful for conditioning dosing) and that some players may run more on turf, but it gives no number you can safely programme by, so surface-specific load adjustments should still be based on your own GPS/wellness monitoring rather than this review's pooled narrative. The isolated finding of greater residual hamstring fatigue after artificial turf exposure is not strong enough to change return-to-play criteria or trigger blanket turf avoidance, but it is reasonable grounds to keep an eye on hamstring readiness in the day or two after turf-heavy exposure, especially in players already flagged as at risk.

In practice

For S&C programming, do not use this review to set turf-versus-grass load targets numerically; keep dosing decisions anchored to the squad's own GPS and wellness data, since a sprint-count difference reported in one study on turf may not replicate in another group. The one practically reliable signal is sand's higher metabolic cost, so when sand is used for conditioning or return-to-running work, expect a given speed to cost more physiologically than the same speed on grass and dose volume or intensity down accordingly rather than matching grass-based targets. In the clinic, the isolated hamstring residual-fatigue finding after artificial turf exposure is not strong enough to alter return-to-play clearance, but it is a reasonable prompt to ask about hamstring readiness and sprint willingness in the 24 to 48 hours after turf-heavy fixtures, particularly in players with a recent hamstring history. Treat any surface-based adjustment, on the clinic floor or the training pitch, as a hypothesis to check against that individual athlete's own monitoring trend, not a standing rule.

Read the primary source ↗

The five papers that matter — every week, free.

We read the whole sports-medicine, rehab & performance literature and appraise the papers worth your time.

Get the free weekly issue

Related appraisals

Read in your language: English · Français · Deutsch · Español · Italiano · Nederlands · Dansk · Svenska