Worth knowing Quality score: 52/100

Player, Coach, and Performance Staff Perceptions of, Experiences with, and Preferences for Nutrition Services Within Rugby: An Implementation‑Focused Qualitative Exploration

Sports medicine - open · 2026

KeyACL Anterior Cruciate LigamentS&C Strength and Conditioning

Rugby dietitians are underused and under-resourced, say staff and players, but this single-club qualitative study can't tell you if fixing that improves outcomes.

The paper

Qualitative study, n=27 (13 players, 5 dietitians, 1 coach, 3 S&C coaches, 3 physiotherapists, 2 high-performance managers) from one Australian professional rugby organisation.

What they found

Thematic analysis generated three themes: dietitian visibility and credibility depend on organisational/leadership value and role clarity; food practices (menus, provision, shared meals, food literacy) are the main delivery vehicle, with gaps concentrated in women's, pathway, and rehabilitation programs and among food-insecure athletes; and limited resourcing forces reactive, inequitable service delivery. No quantitative effect sizes are reported, as this is a qualitative implementation study.

Study design

Qualitative, semi-structured interview study with inductive thematic analysis, framed by the i-PARIHS implementation science model. Single Australian professional rugby organisation, n=27 purposefully sampled participants across player, coaching, medical, and dietetic roles. This sits low on the traditional evidence hierarchy for treatment effect but is an appropriate design for an implementation/perceptions question.

Methodology

Purposeful sampling and multi-rater iterative coding give some rigour, but this is one organisation, so findings may not transfer to clubs with different resourcing, culture, or national context (selection and transferability bias). Online interviews over a long window (April 2024 to July 2025) risk drift in staff roles and organisational policy during data collection. Authors include dietitians/nutrition academics, which is a plausible source of interpretive bias toward advocating for dietitian role expansion; no risk-of-bias or reflexivity framework (e.g. COREQ) is mentioned in the abstract, and inter-rater reliability metrics are not given. A clinician cannot independently verify "gaps were most evident" claims without seeing raw quotes or a frequency/saturation table in the full text.

The appraisal

There is no statistical claim to weigh here, this is hypothesis-generating description, not a test of whether more dietetic staffing improves outcomes. The themes (underresourcing, unclear role authority, inequity in women's and pathway programs) are plausible and consistent with broader sports medicine workforce literature, but the paper cannot support a causal claim that elevating dietitians to full-time integrated roles will improve athlete outcomes, as it did not measure outcomes at all. Interviews were collected over April 2024 to July 2025, a 15-month window within one organisation, so some of what participants describe may reflect a moving target rather than a single fixed state of service delivery.

The gap

No outcome data (performance, injury, body composition, athlete satisfaction) links the proposed service model changes to actual benefit, and the single-organisation sample means we don't know how generalisable these resourcing and equity gaps are across other rugby programs or codes.

Landmark context

This extends the broader sports nutrition workforce and implementation science literature (i-PARIHS has been used across various health implementation contexts) rather than building on a single landmark trial; it is one of relatively few qualitative implementation studies specifically examining dietetic service delivery structures in professional team sport.

What to do Monday

Doesn't change Monday's clinical practice directly, but it is a useful advocacy and service-design reference for performance staff or dietitians arguing for increased staffing, clearer role definition, or equity-focused nutrition provision in women's and pathway programs.

In practice

Treat this as a service-audit prompt, not a protocol change. In rehab caseloads (bone stress injury, ACL, returning pathway players) and women's programs, explicitly check whether dietetic input is actually reaching the athlete rather than assuming it is because a dietitian exists somewhere in the building, those are the exact contexts the paper flags as gaps. On the performance floor, where dietetic contact time is thin, S&C coaches and HP managers should escalate fueling and food-access gaps, especially for pathway and food-insecure athletes, to the dietitian or leadership rather than quietly absorbing nutrition advice-giving themselves, since informal coverage is part of the fragmentation problem described here. Use the findings to push for protected, funded dietitian time with named role authority, but verify locally first: this is one Australian club's account and the specific gaps may not map onto another program's structure or resourcing.

Read the primary source ↗

The five papers that matter — every week, free.

We read the whole sports-medicine, rehab & performance literature and appraise the papers worth your time.

Get the free weekly issue

Read in your language: English · Français · Deutsch · Español · Italiano · Nederlands · Dansk · Svenska