[ Dose·Response ]
Worth knowingQuality score: 40/100

Functional Outcomes After Fracture-Dislocation of the Ankle.

Foot & ankle specialist · 2026

Ankle fracture-dislocations show worse FAOS pain at 3 years than simple fractures, but confounded, underpowered retrospective data can only flag risk, not confirm a true effect.

What they found

Fracture-dislocation patients were older (53 vs 44 years, p=.017), more often female (72.7% vs 51.8%, p=.039) and diabetic (24.2% vs 7.1%, p=.010). FAOS pain subscale was worse in the fracture-dislocation group (76 vs 92, p=.012); function, ADL, sport and QoL subscales and wound complication rates did not differ significantly.

Study design

Retrospective comparative cohort, Level III therapeutic evidence, single surgical centre over 3 years; n=118 eligible (33 fracture-dislocation, 85 fracture-only), n=62 analysed for FAOS at median 37 months follow-up.

Methodology & bias

Charts were reviewed retrospectively for demographics, fracture type, operative time and complications; FAOS was collected only in the subset reaching 12-month follow-up (62/118, 53% capture), creating attrition/selection bias risk if responders differ systematically from the 48% lost to follow-up. There is no randomisation, no blinding of outcome assessment, no standardised rehab protocol described across groups, and no adjustment (regression or matching) for the significant baseline imbalances in age, sex and diabetes before comparing FAOS between groups, so the pain-subscale difference is confounded by design. No power calculation is reported, median follow-up of 37 months likely masks a wide range given retrospective ascertainment, and fracture severity/pattern (e.g. trimalleolar vs bimalleolar, syndesmotic injury) is not controlled for despite being a plausible driver of both dislocation and worse pain.

The appraisal

The FAOS pain gap (76 vs 92, p=.012) is statistically significant but no MCID is reported for FAOS pain in this paper, and a roughly 16-point difference on a 0-100 scale sits in a range that could plausibly be clinically meaningful or could partly reflect residual confounding by age, sex and diabetes rather than the dislocation itself. With only 62 of 118 patients (53%) analysed for outcome, no adjustment for the baseline imbalances, and no power calculation, the null result on function/ADL/sport/QoL subscales is as likely to reflect underpowering as true equivalence, so the design supports an association worth monitoring, not a causal or clinically confirmed deficit.

The gap

Only 53% of the eligible cohort had outcome data and none of the significant demographic imbalances (age, sex, diabetes) were adjusted for in the FAOS comparison, so the isolated pain-subscale finding may reflect confounding rather than a true effect of fracture-dislocation itself.

Landmark context

The authors state prior reporting on ankle fracture-dislocation outcomes specifically is limited; this study adds outcome-score quantification to existing clinical teaching that fracture-dislocations are higher-energy injuries with worse prognosis, without establishing a new mechanism or changing that teaching.

What to do Monday

Flag fracture-dislocation as a marker for closer pain monitoring and earlier expectation-setting post-ORIF, but do not change fixation technique, rehab protocol or discharge criteria on this evidence alone.

Apply this in practice

Physio: on receipt of a post-ORIF ankle referral, check the operative note (or ask the surgeon) to confirm whether the injury was a fracture-dislocation rather than a simple malleolar fracture, since this is not always obvious from the fracture name alone; flag patients who are older, female or diabetic as a higher pain-risk subgroup. Establish a baseline FAOS (or at minimum the pain subscale) at first visit and re-score at 3, 6 and 12 months to track trajectory objectively rather than assuming a standard fracture recovery curve; in diabetic patients also screen for peripheral neuropathy and check recent HbA1c or glycaemic control via GP/surgical notes, since this affects both wound healing and pain reporting. S&C: treat confirmed fracture-dislocation as a flag for criteria-based rather than time-based progression back to loading, plyometrics and impact work, using pain response to graded loading (not a calendar date) as the gating criterion, and loop back to the surgical/physio team if pain plateaus rather than improves. Caveat for both disciplines: this study does not identify which specific interventions close the pain gap, so the actionable change is risk stratification and monitoring frequency, not a new exercise or manual therapy protocol.

Read the paper ↗

Appraise any paper on demand

This is one critical appraisal from Dose-Response. Join and appraise any sports-medicine, rehab or performance paper yourself — plus the five that matter, every week.

Join Dose-Response
Shared from a Dose-Response member’s library. Educational critical appraisal, not medical advice. doseresponse.org