Current Approaches to Arthroscopic Management of Anterior Shoulder Instability.
JBJS reviews · 2026
A useful orientation review on shoulder instability surgery trends, but it's opinion and synthesis, not evidence of superiority for any technique.
What they found
No pooled effect sizes or statistical outcomes are reported; the review states isolated soft-tissue repair is appropriate below roughly 13.5% glenoid bone loss, remplissage indications are expanding to off-track/near-track and subequatorial lesions, and distal tibial allograft reconstruction shows 'excellent short-term outcomes' compared with Latarjet, without quantifying that comparison.
Study design
This is a narrative/expert review, not a systematic review or meta-analysis, with no defined n or single population; it sits at the bottom of the evidence hierarchy, above expert opinion only by virtue of citing primary literature rather than generating it.
Methodology & bias
There is no stated systematic search strategy, no PRISMA flow, no risk-of-bias or GRADE assessment, and no pooled statistics, so this is a narrative synthesis vulnerable to selection and citation bias, the authors choosing studies that support a particular surgical philosophy. Conflict of interest and funding sources are not detailed in the abstract, which matters given the strong pro-surgical framing and the promotion of a newer graft technique (distal tibial allograft) alongside established procedures (Latarjet, Bankart, remplissage).
The appraisal
Everything here is descriptive and opinion-based rather than comparative or causal; phrases like 'excellent short-term outcomes' and 'promising alternative' are unquantified and cannot be weighed against Latarjet's decades of outcome data. It is useful as an orientation piece to current thinking and terminology (glenoid track, on/off-track, remplissage expansion) but should not be read as evidence that any one approach outperforms another.
The gap
No comparative data, no defined complication or recurrence rates, and no long-term follow-up on the distal tibial allograft technique it promotes as an alternative to Latarjet.
Landmark context
This builds directly on the glenoid track concept that reframed bone loss assessment from simple percentage cutoffs to a dynamic humeral-glenoid interaction model, and it extends the ongoing Latarjet-versus-soft-tissue-repair debate that has driven shoulder instability surgery for the past 15 years.
What to do Monday
No, this does not change Monday's practice; it is a useful refresher on current terminology and surgical decision trees but provides no new outcome data to alter referral thresholds or rehab protocols.
Apply this in practice
For the physio managing a first-time anterior dislocator, the practical takeaway is unchanged: screen for bone loss risk factors (age, contact sport, recurrent instability, apprehension at low abduction) and refer early for imaging and surgical opinion if the athlete is young, high-demand, or has any suggestion of bone loss, since this review reinforces that operative management is being pushed earlier in the pathway. On the S&C floor this means return-to-sport timelines and loading progressions should still be built around the specific procedure performed (isolated Bankart, Bankart plus remplissage, Latarjet, or bone block) rather than a generic instability protocol, because the indications for remplissage and bony augmentation are widening, so more athletes will present post-op with combined procedures needing external rotation and overhead loading introduced more cautiously and later. The caveat for both disciplines is that the newer distal tibial allograft technique has no long-term data behind it in this review, so treat any athlete who has had this procedure as a case requiring conservative, individualized progression rather than applying Latarjet-based benchmarks by default.
Appraise any paper on demand
This is one critical appraisal from Dose-Response. Join and appraise any sports-medicine, rehab or performance paper yourself — plus the five that matter, every week.
Join Dose-Response